QNpoohbear: I think it would be okay if the pilgrim girl had more than 2 outfits, I'm not an expert on this in any way, but I think the list could be something like this:
1. Meet dress: simple, solid color wool dress
2. Everyday workdress, in a lighter material like cotton
3. A nightgown of some sort
4. she would have worn a petticoat and undershirt of some kind, wouldn't she?
5. Somekind of winterwear, woolen petticoat, BIG shawl.
Her meet asseccories would be a bonnet, a big white linnen collar, an apron and a sack kind of thing for gathering berries and nuts in.

For asseccories she would need:
Baskets, bowls and different cooking supplies, socks and shoes, knitting pins/ crochet needle, on of those things for butter making(kwim?), a Bible.

Furniture would be a very simple bed, a bench, a table, and a cupboard, and ofcourse lots of homemade blankets to stay varm during winter.

Did I get just someof that right?